So I picked my car up from the bodyshop on Saturday and all in all it seems like a very successful replacement. Checked the door in different lights and the paint match seems very good - can't tell a difference and the reflections all match the same way. When I collected the car the upper seal between the window and the roof had been pulled down, potentially the door was closed before the window was dropping (disconnected battery?) but the person showing me the car and the repair got it all sorted in a matter of seconds. The panel gaps were great, the mirror has been attached properly, no signs of any sanding or blending marks although there was a little polish still around the door handle but it buffed off easily, and there was what seemed to be excess lacquer droplets or something around the boot/engine shut line on the rear wing but they just scraped off leaving a perfect finish underneath. All in all can't fault the repair.
For me the process went as follows: First noticed the paint bubbling on 4th May 2023 (car delivered 15th Nov 2022) and sent an email with pictures to the dealer and Lotus Customer Care on the same day. I heard back from Lotus Glasgow's service manager on the 5th. On the 9th of May they asked for the VIN of the car and were in contact with Lotus directly, and a local bodyshop to progress with a repair. On the 10th of May I was contacted by the bodyshop and arranged to come by for them to inspect the car. At the bodyshop they recognised the issue straight away as they had seen it on another car with a similar material type and they initially repainted them only for the issue to return and it was full replacement that was needed, and they communicated that back to Lotus.
My next update was on June 14th when I learned that Lotus had approved the new door, and the bodyshop would be in touch to arrange a date to get the replacement done. There was then silence on the door until 16th of October when I was called by the bodyshop to say the door was due in imminently and an appointment was set for it to be dropped off on the 13th of November and the job was due to take around 6 days. On the 21st Nov I was called and told the door seals had failed and about an inch of water was sitting inside the door and so the seals need replaced and are on back order with no ETA. Furthermore due to the paint blending the factory PPF would also need replaced and was also on back order, but luckily a local company was able to replace this. On the 8th of Dec they said that one of the three seals had arrived with the rest expected in a few days, and then the car was finally ready to collect on the 14th.
Other than waiting a long time the whole process was relatively pain free and I didn't need to chase up the dealer or Lotus much at all. It may have happened faster with more pestering, but it was all done eventually and in my case at least appears to be a good quality repair.