On top of the Cayman, or whatever it is now called, being ugly IMHO, I can also not shake away that 'poor man's Porsche' thought in my head. I'd always desire a 911, any 911, well over ANY Cayman.
That's just me. I understand that the Cayman in some forms is considered a real weapon.
Tough to call yourself a car person if you’d take a base 911 over say a GT4RS.