Part 2: the the conventional format of feedback on different aspects of the car
I did 3 Emira test drives:
- Two at Bell & Colvill Lotus Surrey: Nimbus Grey, red leather interior, leather steering wheel, Touring suspension, Goodyear tyres. Driven daytime into dusk (2,000 miles on car so fully run in, using full rev range and Tour, Sport and Track drive modes) and early morning (nearly 3,000 miles but temperatures below freezing so only in Tour drive mode). The test route is all on local roads I know well.
- One at Caffyns Lotus Ashford: Hethel Yellow, alcantara interior and wheel, Sports suspension, Goodyear tyres. Driven in daytime (1,500 miles so no rev restrictions, 3-4 degrees and only Tour and Sport drive modes).
Me: 5'9" / 175cm with relatively shorter legs and longer body, 12st6 / 174 lbs / 79 kg, shoe UK size 9 / EU 43 / US 9 or 9.5
Exterior: looks great, we all know this! It turns heads everywhere - on part of one test route we passed a school at going home time and ALL the kids and parents stopped and pointed and waved (of course this was in the Hethel Yellow car!)
Access: straightforward, easier than an early Evora and slightly easier than a late model 4xx Evora.
Seats: were fine for me in terms of holding me securely and comfortably; if other people hadn't highlighted some concerns I wouldn't have given them a second thought. I tried both leather and alcantara and they were equally comfortable and supportive on brisk drives. On both cars/both materials the seat base was showing some signs of sag in the material after only a few thousand miles.
Driving position: I could get into a good position but was surprised I was at the lowest setting on the seat and the highest height adjustment on the steering wheel to then be able to see all of the drivers display. The rev display is at the top edge (in Tour/Sport) so you need to be able to get your eyeline right. In all other respects the position was great and everything fell to your hands and feet as expected. It felt just right and my co-pilot observed I'd got comfortable with the car within a few hundred yards. No worries about pedal offsets or spacing, access to controls or buttons or displays.
Visibility: great forwards to the front wing arches (Becker points) to place the car. The downslope at the top front of the doors means you get good visibility to the side and of the mirrors, which in turn give you good rear visibility to supplement the rear view mirror. View out the back is similar to the Evora, so not great but fine in conjunction with the side mirrors. I was surprised to find the adjustment of the rear view mirror was partly blocked by the pod mounting it to the windscreen, making it hard to turn the mirror more to the drivers side.
Interior: the cabin is a nice place to be, the materials are good and it's well-built. The stitch lines are really sharp. There are echoes of the Esprit cabin in how the design flows from the doors into the dash and the position of the shifter. The controls, buttons and switchgear mostly look and feel great, a couple feel a bit cheaper. Driver display is good in the different modes, visible in sun and at night, configurable widgets are useful. I still would prefer analogue-looking gauges!
Steering wheel: takes a moment to get used to the shape then it's soon forgotten. Driving both leather and alcantara wheels on the same day, I noticed the layout of the stitching on the leather wheel was slightly more awkward and a bit distracting when doing larger turns where you needed to move your grip mid-turn. I think the alcantara wheel has less stitching around the hand positions so feels slightly smoother to use, which I hadn't expected.
Clutch, gearbox, transmission: felt very familiar after various Evoras. Clutch bite point varied between cars, as others have observed, but was easily found and soon learnt, with no issues with stalling. Changing gear requires a deliberate action, same as the Evora, and the box doesn't like to be rushed, particularly if you try to make a change too quickly near to redline. Once you learn the engine characteristic across the rev range it's easy to ignore the rev counter and up-shift lights and just anticipate where to change up to get close to redline but not hit the limiter. Being used to the supercharged V6 made it easier to pick this up in a short test drive. On the B&C test drive I did a few full bore runs from standing and rolling starts to check out the linearity and pull across the range. I'm a fan of the V6 SC (I've driven one for 11 years) and the combination of low end torque and linear power delivery. As I've mentioned before, there isn't an obvious "topping out" on the power delivery, so you have to use revs or shift lights or learn the feel of where the shift point is. Country roads around me are easily covered by 2nd and 3rd gear. It was interesting to note the slight but noticeable difference in gear change smoothness, engine freedom and exhaust noise driving the same car at 2,000 and 3,000 miles - things were still bedding in.
Noise: inside the cabin you get more transmission and supercharger noise and less exhaust noise than I expected, even in Sport or Track. This is particularly so at lower revs, where the transmission noise reminds me of a straight cut race box until you increase the revs and the supercharger whine takes over. It's a different sound to the Evora and some will prefer more exhaust note - this is improved by opening the windows! For others a decat or sports exhaust will add enough. For the intended daily driver target it's probably about right.
Steering, suspension, ride and handling: the chassis, steering and suspension are brilliantly capable. You get the directness of feedback from the road you expect with a Lotus and an ability to flow down a country road, even ones with some really bad surfaces and changes of camber. On the B&C test route there is a fast downhill section into a left-hander with a large diagonal depression in the road from a sunken drain, which badly unsettles most cars. The Emira tells you exactly what's happening and flows through it at speed with no concerns about losing traction or steering precision. Further on, we stopped to get a clear full bore start and accelerate through a really badly pot-holed section and the car just took it in it's stride without skipping traction or the steering being diverted. This was with a Touring suspension setup.
Suspension - Touring and Sports: as you know from my comparison thread
here, I'm an advocate of matching suspension choice to your intended use. I've said before that I thought Touring would suit the majority of daily drivers using roads with a mixture of surface qualities. My test drive confirmed that - the setup has the great Lotus "flow" on uneven roads and is composed on off-cambers and pot holes without being wallowy or having too much roll. It feels very similar to my Evora S, which is the comparison Lotus had advised. Sports is flat and taut through fast changes of direction, with less roll - not better, just slightly different. There is some extra feel through the steering but also extra fidgeting at the front end, a slight jiggling even over fairly smooth surfaces. You are more aware of uneven surfaces and pot holes, but it's not crashy. It is sensitive to off-cambers and it tramlines more on worn roads. It would potentially be more wearing on a long journey but would be fine for weekend use and if you are blessed with smooth roads. The feel is very close to the Evora GT410 (US GT), so that is a good alternative to test drive. Both drove as I expected they would based on my Evora S/Evora GT410 experiences.
Brakes: were great, I agree with comments from others about slight grabbing at low speed, but easy to calibrate your brain to it. More frustrating was the e-brake - I hate them on a manual and this was no exception! It was also disappointing that the release button and surround are noticeably cheaper-feeling than the other switches and buttons.
Drive modes: interesting to note that Sport drive mode gives you more exhaust noise but doesn't significantly alter the TC/ESC programme in normal driving (there's no throttle reduction if understeer is detected - it is reduced in Tour). This is different to Sport drive mode on the Evora, where greater yaw angle and tyre slip is allowed, so you can get the back to step out more easily. This is clearly a safety/everyday driving thing but does mean you have to use Track to get a bit more playfulness, but this means you have a lot of TC/ESC off or minimised and are largely on your own. Tour-Sport-Track-Off feel more evenly spaced on the Evora.
Infotainment, satnav, audio: apparently there's some half-decent tech in the car. I usually drive with the window down to listen to the exhaust noise better and have a phone mount to run Waze on my mobile, so I supposed CarPlay might be useful
Yes, there are a few annoying or disappointing items, but they are mostly small and out-weighed by considering the whole. As a complete package aimed at a daily driver, it's the best car Lotus has produced so far, which is a great achievement.
But in my opinion it's not the best drivers car they've produced. To get that you have to compromise on practicality and accessibility (and - subjectively - looks) and go into the back catalogue. The potential is there in the Emira foundations to suggest a lighter, noisier, faster, sharper GT version could take that crown.