Emira Review Index [V6 FE]

EyeFour Eemeerah! · Aug 8, 2023

Quite frankly, if a reviewers prerequisite is to explore forums, biases and mechanical history PRIOR to doing a review, the review in and of itself is tainted. They are unable to portray their reactions, positives and negatives that they find with a car, because they are now looking for those little niggles that forum members may have found. And they may never find them!! To wish to glean an “unbiased review” from Consumer Reports is an act of futility! They‘re extremely biased and incentivize their reviewers with post-review purchase abilities - speaking from experience. As people view their preferred outlets for reviewers and automotive digests, they establish an expectation of review style. It is these which we weight accordingly, as to who aligns most closely with our findings.

Keep in mind as well, that these are new cars, with all their warts and growing pains, that need to work themselves out. It’s essentially been a two year R&D project which is now coming to fruition. They’ll get there, while retaining the charm that you all are accustomed to! As for me, this will be my first venture in the world of Lotus, and I can only hope for the best!

Pegasi · Aug 8, 2023

Porter said:
I think people are just sick and tired of the disingenuity of the review format. Many of these videos reviews have presenters that act like they are playing to a broadcast television camera, when in reality they are posting a video on the internet. The content should be as frank as any Reddit post, but it isn't, it's sanitized and excessively careful and polite.

The thing that I suspect many people would like to see, myself included, is for a respected reviewer to look directly into the camera and say out loud that Lotus is delivering cars to owners that should never have left the factory. Look in the camera and say that from reports from the ownership community, Lotus are utterly dropping the ball in dozens of different ways, from product quality to service response to communication, and that someone in leadership needs to get their act together and take management responsibility. Preferably in a way that places the customer as the most important stakeholder.

In the absence of some real, direct talk into a camera about what the challenges are with this company, all these reviews are different forms of fluff that aren't particularly relevant to the ownership experience.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not canceling my order, but at the same time I have basically no expectation that Lotus will be able to competently service or repair the car if and when I do have a problem, and so I'm fully planning to take on that responsibility myself. Think about how absurd it is that I would even need to think about that in the year 2023.

Completely disagree. You are asking for a journalistic expose regarding the actions of a car maker based on unsubstantiated posts from anonymous forums users. You would need a news organization who understands how to verify facts. I always thought the reviews were reporting on the car and it's attributes. You speak of "direct talk into a camera about what the challenges are with this company" and I am not sure a youtube reviewer should get into that. Quite frankly I would believe you more than any reviewer, your posts have been consistent, accurate, and unbiased. I believe the reviewers are doing their job and I believe the forum is doing it's job. I have always had the unpopular opinion on this.

Eagle7 · Aug 8, 2023

Porter said:
I think people are just sick and tired of the disingenuity of the review format. Many of these videos reviews have presenters that act like they are playing to a broadcast television camera, when in reality they are posting a video on the internet. The content should be as frank as any Reddit post, but it isn't, it's sanitized and excessively careful and polite.

The thing that I suspect many people would like to see, myself included, is for a respected reviewer to look directly into the camera and say out loud that Lotus is delivering cars to owners that should never have left the factory. Look in the camera and say that from reports from the ownership community, Lotus are utterly dropping the ball in dozens of different ways, from product quality to service response to communication, and that someone in leadership needs to get their act together and take management responsibility. Preferably in a way that places the customer as the most important stakeholder.

In the absence of some real, direct talk into a camera about what the challenges are with this company, all these reviews are different forms of fluff that aren't particularly relevant to the ownership experience.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not canceling my order, but at the same time I have basically no expectation that Lotus will be able to competently service or repair the car if and when I do have a problem, and so I'm fully planning to take on that responsibility myself. Think about how absurd it is that I would even need to think about that in the year 2023.

I always have a great deal of respect for your opinion and input because you've proven yourself respectable in here. However in this instance, I'm going to somewhat disagree because what you're advocating here isn't a car review, it's a company review. That's certainly a valid topic, but a different thing from reviewing a car.

Having been part of the rollout of the first Alfa Romeo Giulias in the U.S. (still have mine, it's a great car) I can say that while the car is fantastic, FCA at the time sucked (they've been acquired by Stellantis). There were many issues with the early cars, software updates etc. just like here with Lotus. I got lucky; my car has been an absolute jewel. No problems. Just yesterday, I finally had to replace the battery after 6 years (original factory battery) which is EXTREMELY unusual for Alfas, especially the early ones. That's not something I posted in the Alfa forums because who cares? There were a lot of posts from people about the issues they were having, many were with FCA who owned Alfa, as well as Alfa themselves. They delivered cars that should never have left the factory, but they also delivered mine which is a wonderful car.

It may be worthwhile to have a separate forum category for company reviews and/or dealer reviews, as opposed to car reviews which are always going to be about that specific car the reviewer has and is driving.

Like you, I am also going to receive my car with the expectation that, as it always has with any sports car I've ever owned, it will be on me to make it work and keep on working. Unless I get a jewel car like my Alfa, I expect I might be working on it from time to time. I'll buy the manual, and look through it and the car to familiarize myself with things. It's a Lotus, and I've had a Lotus before, but the moment I saw it I had that unmistakeable instinct feeling that this one was going to be worth the experience. I called the closest dealer (500 miles away) and put down a deposit immediately. I had that same instinct feeling when I first drove the Alfa, and it turned out that the car I drove at the dealership was the one I actually bought. My gut instinct has never let me down. The only time it's been a problem was when I didn't listen to it, and I always regretted it afterwards. I've never regretted listening to it. Can't wait to get my car.

Johnson · Aug 8, 2023

If this was a forum about Sunbeam toasters, half the posts would be complaints about how slow/dark/light/noisy it was (no offence to Sunbeam toasters, even though they suck).

Reviewers shouldn’t concentrate on faults, or no one would ever buy a car (take the McLaren engine fire as an example). And fortunately, most car faults car be fixed!

pancho · Aug 8, 2023

Ho raggiunto oggi i 1300 km e sto finendo il rodaggio quindi ho iniziato a superare i 4000 giri raccomandati e mi sono spinto fino a 6000

, come già detto altre volte la mia v6 fe ha un handling pazzesco e mi fanno le foto per strada. Consuma il giusto e se proprio dovessi trovargli dei difetti direi il cambio automatico che non è come un pdk ma basta farci l'abitudine e la ripresa che a mio avviso fino a 4000 giri è un po' fiacca rispetto a porsche aspirato di pari cubatura.

Google Translation:

I reached 1300 km today and I'm finishing the run-in so I started to exceed the recommended 4000 laps and I pushed myself up to 6000

, as already mentioned other times my v6 fe has a crazy handling and they take pictures of me on the road. It consumes the right and if I really had to find faults I would say the automatic transmission that is not like a pdk but just get used to it and the recovery that in my opinion up to 4000 rpm is a bit weak compared to porsche aspirated of equal volume.

SPoivre · Aug 11, 2023

I didn’t see where this review was already posted. It seems like a nice down to earth review where, in a short section of it, the presenter goes over some of the interior shared parts with Proton/Geely without getting wigged out.

He doesn’t mention the door pulls but I think I saw those in a Geely model a while back although Lotus may have flipped them upside down. (Ie swapped left for right)

Porter · Aug 11, 2023

Pegasi said:
Completely disagree. You are asking for a journalistic expose regarding the actions of a car maker based on unsubstantiated posts from anonymous forums users. You would need a news organization who understands how to verify facts. I always thought the reviews were reporting on the car and it's attributes. You speak of "direct talk into a camera about what the challenges are with this company" and I am not sure a youtube reviewer should get into that. Quite frankly I would believe you more than any reviewer, your posts have been consistent, accurate, and unbiased. I believe the reviewers are doing their job and I believe the forum is doing it's job. I have always had the unpopular opinion on this.

I think what I'm driving at is that the missing link right now in automotive reviewing is the frankness - and direct dressing down of companies when necessary - that was done by the original trio at Top Gear during drive reviews.

I think as a buying public, we really need people with enough industry clout (and also a-hole tendencies) to be able to look into a camera and say, "this product is brilliant and so are the people who build it, but the company is rubbish."

GlobalPilot777 · Aug 28, 2023

If anybody cares about autotopnl, i like the raw reviews of this guy..

Disappointing topspeed tho… too ages fo reach 279/280… 290 maybe downhill otherwise forget it

EyeFour Eemeerah! · Aug 28, 2023

Globalpilot777 said:
If anybody cares about autotopnl, i like the raw reviews of this guy..

Disappointing topspeed tho… too ages fo reach 279/280… 290 maybe downhill otherwise forget it

Ashame someone put a bulge in the middle front hood! How if there is no frunk?

lynchy73 · Aug 28, 2023

Globalpilot777 said:
If anybody cares about autotopnl, i like the raw reviews of this guy..

Disappointing topspeed tho… too ages fo reach 279/280… 290 maybe downhill otherwise forget it

He doesn’t hang about and top speed looked pretty quick to me.

Seems like 6th is geared a bit too long geared for the motor’s power level. I’m sure a slightly higher redline, a bit more power and slightly reduced final drive would do the trick. That or more power to pull the existing gearing which would get you to over 300km/h if you could pull max revs in 6th

EZcheezy · Aug 28, 2023

i dont understand why anyone would care about top speed. I often get asked that by non-car people and I usually dont even have that the number memorized. other than the ones near the autobahn none of us can actually reach it

Pegasi · Aug 28, 2023

EZcheezy said:
i dont understand why anyone would care about top speed. I often get asked that by non-car people and I usually dont even have that the number memorized. other than the ones near the autobahn none of us can actually reach it

There are some tracks near me in the USA that have long straights that allow for top speed tests.

Porter · Aug 28, 2023

Pegasi said:
There are some tracks near me in the USA that have long straights that allow for top speed tests.

Not like that. It's not even particularly relevant on most long road courses. On almost any car the top speed is aerodynamically limited, so after the main acceleration period you approach the top speed number very slowly. Maybe on a big oval top speed would be relevant? But who wants to run on that?

I find it interesting that automotive journalism hasn't come up with a metric for this. Absolute top speed is sort of irrelevant, what people generally want to know is how high it goes while still accelerating quickly. Something like the 3dB down point on a subwoofer or pair of speakers, i.e. how low can it go while still giving meaningful "full" performance. We don't have a metric like that for cars that I know of.

kitkat · Aug 28, 2023

EyeFour Eemeerah! said:
Ashame someone put a bulge in the middle front hood! How if there is no frunk?

Must be a defect because the hood is GRP, they don't dent or anything.

KAR120C · Aug 28, 2023

Porter said:
Not like that. It's not even particularly relevant on most long road courses. On almost any car the top speed is aerodynamically limited, so after the main acceleration period you approach the top speed number very slowly. Maybe on a big oval top speed would be relevant? But who wants to run on that?

I find it interesting that automotive journalism hasn't come up with a metric for this. Absolute top speed is sort of irrelevant, what people generally want to know is how high it goes while still accelerating quickly. Something like the 3dB down point on a subwoofer or pair of speakers, i.e. how low can it go while still giving meaningful "full" performance. We don't have a metric like that for cars that I know of.

I totally agree. I've always wished for a 50-100mph, or similar, measurement that is meaningful for real world use.

Pegasi · Aug 28, 2023

Porter said:
Not like that. It's not even particularly relevant on most long road courses. On almost any car the top speed is aerodynamically limited, so after the main acceleration period you approach the top speed number very slowly. Maybe on a big oval top speed would be relevant? But who wants to run on that?

I find it interesting that automotive journalism hasn't come up with a metric for this. Absolute top speed is sort of irrelevant, what people generally want to know is how high it goes while still accelerating quickly. Something like the 3dB down point on a subwoofer or pair of speakers, i.e. how low can it go while still giving meaningful "full" performance. We don't have a metric like that for cars that I know of.

I do understand this but there are tracks where people will compare their top speed. The original comment mentioned the autobahn and why people care about top speed. There are tracks where people will remember the highest speed they can achieve, it may not be the top speed. Lots of different car enthusiasts experiencing and enjoying cars in different ways.

Porter · Aug 28, 2023

Pegasi said:
I do understand this but there are tracks where people will compare their top speed. The original comment mentioned the autobahn and why people care about top speed. There are tracks where people will remember the highest speed they can achieve, it may not be the top speed. Lots of different car enthusiasts experiencing and enjoying cars in different ways.

Oh I totally agree. Things like "It was fast, I hit 148 on the back straight at Road Atlanta". But that's not really relevant to the published top speed of a car. It's a great metric for accelerative potential in a certain specific context though, and really informs people who know exactly what it means. The challenge I think is that we lack a common metric for that as a thing people can understand in contexts other than a particular racetrack... an anecdotal understanding of which is only shared by a vanishingly small percentage of the interested, buying public.

ino · Aug 29, 2023

Not that much “review”, but it is great movie.

eriegz · Sep 16, 2023

ino said:
Not that much “review”, but it is great movie.

Wow, I don't think I've seen anybody who loves cars as much as this woman does. Haha

Cachaco131 · Sep 16, 2023

Misha and Tour suspension

Reviewer	Type	Direct Link
Edmunds	Article	New Lotus Emira Is Worth the Wait \| Edmunds The 2022 Lotus Emira, powered by a supercharged 3.5-liter V6, is both the end and the beginning of an era as the automaker transitions to a world of fully electrified supercars and crossovers. www.edmunds.com
Harry's Garage (Harry Metcalfe)	Video Review	Harry drives the Sports and Tour suspension back to back on the same road and shares his thoughts.
Schmee150 (Tim Burton)	Video Review	Published 21st June Bought the Right Car?! LOTUS EMIRA V6 FIRST DRIVE The countdown is on! The folks at Lotus have delivered an Emira V6 First Edition to @TheShmuseum in a near-identical spec to my inbound car, to take for a fi... www.youtube.com
Carwow (Mat Watson)	Video Review	Lotus Emira review - and my BANNED test! Looking to sell your car? Then you've come to the right place. carwow is the free, easy way to change your car online. Check it out here: https://bit.ly/Buy-... www.youtube.com
TopGear	Articles and Video	Published 3rd July Chris Harris talks about the Lotus Emira Chris Harris On… The All-New Lotus Emira \| Top Gear Series 32 “I’d feel a bit scared if I were a McLaren or an Aston Martin at the moment” Chris Harris chats to Top Gear Magazine’s Jack Rix about the all-new Lotus Emira... youtu.be Published 20th June Lotus Emira Review 2023 \| Top Gear The last ever petrol-powered Lotus looks fantastic and drives with precision, but not quite as much emotion as we might’ve hoped www.topgear.com The big sportscar test: Lotus Emira vs Porsche Cayman vs Alpine A110 www.topgear.com
AutoTrader (Rory Reid)	Video Review	NEW Lotus Emira: The Last REAL Lotus? \| 4K Rory reviews the new Lotus Emira, Lotus' last ever petrol sports car. Soon the company will transition to electric cars, but for this last hurrah the Emira p... www.youtube.com
Evo	Article and Video Review	2023 Lotus Emira review – strong showing for Porsche Cayman GTS rival \| Evo The first new Lotus for a generation, and the last to be petrol powered, shows great promise but needs some polish www.evo.co.uk
CAR	Article and Video Review	Published 22nd July Lotus Emira vs Porsche Cayman GTS vs Alpine A110 group test review CAR magazine UK compares the Lotus Emira sports car with the Porsche 718 Cayman GTS 4.0 and Alpine A110 S www.carmagazine.co.uk Lotus Emira (2023) review: new 2.0-litre engine driven The brand new Lotus Emira, tested on road and track by CAR magazine. www.carmagazine.co.uk Lotus Emira vs Cayman 718 GTS vs Alpine 110s
Autocar	Article and Video Review	Lotus Emira V6 First Edition 2022 UK first drive \| Autocar Most important Lotus in decades heralds a new era and sees out an old one, being the firm's last petrol sports car www.autocar.co.uk
Pistonheads	Article	2022 Lotus Emira \| PH Review The Emira is one step closer to production-ready. And the good news (mostly) keeps coming www.pistonheads.com
KHTV	Video Review
The Drive	Article	2023 Lotus Emira First Drive Review: Lotus Grows Up, and Just in Time The Lotus Emira is the last of its kind, the final gas-powered car from the legendary company. And what a thrilling sendoff it is. www.thedrive.com
AutoExpress	Article	New Lotus Emira V6 First Edition review \| Auto Express We hit road and track in the new Lotus Emira - the model that redefines the brand as a sports car maker www.autoexpress.co.uk Pictures: New Lotus Emira 2022 review - pictures \| Auto Express Pictures of the new Lotus Emira www.autoexpress.co.uk
WhichCar	Article	2022 Lotus Emira review: V6 First Edition, international launch Lotus wants to compete with daily-driver premium sportscars like the Cayman and its new Emira V6 First Edition is a big step in the right direction www.whichcar.com.au
CarBuyer	Article	Lotus Emira coupe review \| Carbuyer “The Emira marks a big step on in terms of design and quality for Lotus, and it’s great to drive” www.carbuyer.co.uk
Hagerty	Article	Lotus Emira first drive review: Will the fab four become the famous five? \| Hagerty UK Is the Emira good enough to turn the fab four – Elite, Elan, Esprit, Elise – into the famous five? Read Andrew Frankel's review to find out. www.hagerty.co.uk
Road and Track	Article	Published 1st September Lotus Emira Road and Track Drive The Lotus Emira Is One of the Greats Lotus's final combustion-engined sports car starts a new era for the English automaker, and a prime example of what a well-funded Lotus can build. www.roadandtrack.com The 2023 Emira Is an All-Time High For Lotus The Emira comes from a bygone era. www.roadandtrack.com
Goodwood	Article	First Drive: Lotus Emira 2022 Review \| GRR The Emira is the final combustion-engined Lotus, and it might finally be a match for the Porsche Cayman... www.goodwood.com
The Intercooler	Podcast	Reasonably good post-embargo Emira discussion on The Intercooler. Apple Podcasts Web Embed embed.podcasts.apple.com
Motortrend	Article	2023 Lotus Emira First Drive Review: The Porsche Substitute Don’t want a Porsche Cayman? Try this. www.motortrend.com
Drive	Article	2022 Lotus Emira review: International first drive With a reborn and reinvigorated Lotus looking to a new and very different future, is the Emira the first excuse-free Lotus? www.drive.com.au
AFR	Article	Lotus takes on Porsche with its $185,000 Emira This is a street car for buyers who appreciate luxury and great looks – although with a claimed top speed of 290km/h, it’s no slouch on the racetrack. www.afr.com
Parkers	Article	Lotus Emira Review (2024) Lotus Emira (2024) in-depth review. Read our experts' views on the engine, practicality, running costs, overall performance and more. www.parkers.co.uk
CarExpert	Article	2023 Lotus Emira review: First drive We drive the last Lotus without electrification around Mount Panorama to see if it's a worthy contender to the Porsche 718 Cayman. www.carexpert.com.au
Caffeine & Machine	Article	Caffeine & Machine Hitting the Alps in the summer, chasing the #cultofmachine in the brand spanking new Lotus Emira. Soul food at its best, delivered in spades across the myriad of special alpine roads littering the... www.facebook.com Photos on Instagram: Caffeine&Machine on Instagram: "Hitting the Alps in the summer, chasing the #cultofmachine in the brand spanking new Lotus Emira. Soul food at its best, delivered in spades across the myriad of special alpine roads littering the region. It would be 1,055 likes, 8 comments - caffeineandmachine on June 13, 2022: "Hitting the Alps in the summer, chasing the #cultofmachine in the brand spanking new Lotus Emira. Soul food at its best, delivered in spades across the myriad of special alpine roads littering the region. It would be so easy to... www.instagram.com
The Sunday Times Driving	Article	Lotus Emira V6 2022 on-track review: Lotus's last petrol car is more than significant ... it's good This isn't going to be one of our usual reviews, because our test drive of the new Lotus Emira wasn't usual, either, having experienced just three and a half laps behind the wheel around Goodwood Motor Circuit,. www.driving.co.uk
Car and Driver	Article	2023 Emira Is a Grown-Up Lotus The last gas-powered Lotus also may be the first you don't have to make excuses for. www.caranddriver.com
The Sun	Article	I've driven the Lotus Emira - you can use it every day and it's saving BRITAIN THERE’S only one type of person who wouldn’t fall in love with the Lotus Emira. Those Twitter-dwelling keyboard warriors who think they know more about cars than everyone else. I’ve seen a few comm… www.thesun.co.uk
AutoCar UK	Article	Published 2nd July Lotus Emira vs Porsche 718 Cayman \| Autocar Lotus’s new sports car is a great car in its own right - but can it hold its own against the class leader? www.autocar.co.uk

Emira Review Index [V6 FE]

Emira Fan

Emira Maniac

Emira Aficionado

Emira Fanatic

Active member

Well-known member

Emira Eccentric

Emira Fan

Emira Fan

Emira Fanatic

Emira Fanatic

Emira Maniac

Emira Eccentric

Emira Degenerate

Get off my lawn!

Emira Maniac

Emira Eccentric

Emira Fan

Emira Maniac

Emira Maniac

Early review teaser!

Steve Sutcliffe review

Emira Forum Images

Emira Forum Images

Similar threads