I have had a dozen Porsches in my 50+ years of driving (still have a 993 C4), and I think the Cayman 4.0 is probably technically better than the Emira in every single way- performance, reliability, usability, comfort, luggage space, resale value, etc., etc., etc.
But the Cayman is so plain-jane, so ordinary, so boring in appearance, I just could not force myself to order one, although I've gone through the configurator several times.
And so I am waiting for an imperfect but gorgeous and dramatic Emira.
We are all just lucky that in these EV times, several manufacturers are still making gas-powered enthusiast cars that are each amazing in their own ways.