I like it. I like it a lot. I like the boldness and angularity. I does not not bother me that most people don't like it (perhaps somehow I like it more). In contrast to most people I did not like the prior generation. Kind of chunky and compressed, did not like the presence, It looks to me like a toy car in a bad way.... it lacked a bit of intimidation imo. I like more angular cars, like the original e30. I think most are not just used to the looks and then a lot people will warm up to it, like with the new m3/m4. Call me different I guess. I think this car has a personality and the fact we are here typing means it generates emotions for good or bad, which is not a bad thing..... at least BMW is not being boring and bland with their designs.... applaud that. I don't mind some (mild) disproportions in design, it make things interesting and gives character. Often time well proportion cars (and objects) are boring to look Definitively I'd take this over the old one. The weight is in fact an issue but safety, regulations etc probably are in part the reason.... however lighter versions will come