If the GT4 was $127,000 would the Emira be ok then priced at $119?
It's more about comparables. Certain cars get compared to each other (C63 vs M3 vs RS5). Generally each one offers something unique but are close in price.
The GTS is what lotus said the Emira would be competing against ($95k CAD). Like it or not the vast majority of people who made deposits did so based off the way the car was marketed. Everything talked about is as a Cayman S/GTS competitor. At this point the 4 cylinder is a joke.
The shock is the fact that it comes in at the price of a known track weapon that is a Cayman GT4. This is the top of the line from porsche as far as that segment goes.
My frustration comes from both my customers but from me also witnessing the same thing happening again in Canada.
When the Evora S came out, it was a 911 competitor and a C8 competitor.
See this old top gear article:
https://www.topgear.com/car-news/lotus-evora-vs-porsche-911
https://www.popularmechanics.com/cars/reviews/a6737/2011-lotus-evora-s-test-drive/
They brought it with a price higher than the 911 and the C8 corvette. People bought the early models on hype. Then quality issues came, then dealership network issues came, then people starting dragging lotus through the mud.
A full decade later, I'm still in the business witnessing de ja vu. With the same engine and basically a redone Evora. You would think over a decade later with the same engine the car would be cheaper.
This comment is 10 years old about the Evora S.
"If we were plunking down nearly a hundred grand for a car this exotic, we'd expect more from the drivetrain. Don't get us wrong: We love Toyota's confidence-inspiring reliability."
Nobody except a forumla 1 driver paid by lotus has reviewed that car. Wait till journalist get their hands on it. A decade of automotive progress and you're still doing the same thing. Wait till every review you read mentions the cayman in it and how a toyota engine from 2005 is still in the Emira